Refund Policy


If you are not satisfied with your order from Anstine’s Candy, you may return it within 30 days and we will either credit your card or provide store credit (your choice). Before sending your return, please contact us so we can decide how to best resolve the issue (in some cases a return is not necessary to receive a replacement.)*

Phone: 1-800-226-3925
or click here to email us

Unfortunately, we cannot offer a credit for your shipping charges or fees paid to customs for international shipments.*

You may send your return to:
Anstine’s Candy
35 N Main
Red Lion, PA 17356

* Exceptions may include damaged or incorrect items – but will still be at the discretion of Anstine’s Candy.